While today’s Congressional politics may seem somewhat distasteful to fans of decorum, Capitol Hill’s past is full of far more vicious conflict between ideological opposites. As noted in this New York Times report from 1856, the people’s representatives were once none-too-shy about resorting to the gun or sword when positions seemed irreconcilable—though, to the American politicians’ credit, they were not quite as violent as their British counterparts:
Duels have been fought by members of Congress from the very commencement of our existence as a nation, but these affairs have been much less frequent than is generally supposed to be the case. In fact all of the Congressional challenges that have been sent from the meeting of the first Congress in Philadelphia down to the affair between Brooks and Burlingame, do not exceed twenty-five in number, not half so many as have been fought by members of British Parliament….The records will prove that there has been less of personal violence, and fewer encounters in our Congress than there have been in Parliament, during the same number of years, since the Declaration of Independence.
If we had to pick our favorite Congressional duel, Mason versus McCarty would top the list. The Bladensburg Dueling Grounds was the Thunderdome of its day.
scottstev // Feb 2, 2010 at 4:27 pm
Of course the most prominent incident of Congressional violence was the canning attack on Senator Charles Sumner”. It’s notable that he was bludgeoned as a common ruffian and challenged to a duel among social equals. It’s a another case where Southern bellicosity won immediate concessions, yet fed the later determination of the North for total victory.
scottstev // Feb 2, 2010 at 4:28 pm
Sorry, there’s a missing “not” in “and not challenged to a duel among social equals.
Brendan I. Koerner // Feb 2, 2010 at 4:32 pm
Yep, great point. That incident only popped to mind after I posted this. Thanks for bringing it up.
Whenever I read about the Sumner incident, my mind can’t help but wander to Taiwan’s rollicking national legislature:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=voJ9c0BKJrY#t=38s
Brian Moore // Feb 3, 2010 at 10:24 am
I can’t say I’d complain too much if a few senators got punched a couple times a day.